Contact Us for a Free Consultation 570-468-7603


The Relinquishing Father: A Family Business Fable

Posted by Scott Lynett, Esq. | Aug 18, 2023 | 2 Comments

This week's blog is a fable about one of the most difficult parts of family business succession: giving up control. I hope you enjoy it.

A small coastal town, known for its charming streets and fishing community, was home to the Martin family's seafood business. For generations, the business had thrived, becoming a part of the very fabric of the town. Under the current leadership of Samuel Martin, it reached new heights, with the help of his son, Ethan.

Ethan had worked at Martin's Seafood since he was a child, learning the ins and outs of the family trade. Over the years, he had introduced innovative methods and technology, bringing a fresh perspective to an otherwise traditional business. His father, however, was reluctant to embrace change, holding onto the reins of control with a grip as tight as an oyster shell.

One summer day, as they were inspecting a shipment of freshly caught fish, Ethan approached his father with a heavy heart.

"Dad," Ethan began, looking into Samuel's wise yet stubborn eyes, "I've been thinking a lot about our business and my role in it."

Samuel, noticing the seriousness in his son's voice, put down his clipboard and faced him. "What's on your mind, Ethan? You know you can tell me anything."

Ethan took a deep breath. "Dad, I love this business. It's been my life's work, just as it has been yours. But I feel like I've hit a wall. I've tried to bring new ideas to the table, to modernize our operations, but you always shut me down. It's like you don't trust me to make decisions."

Samuel's face tightened. "Son, it's not about trust. It's about preserving the essence of what made Martin's Seafood what it is. We can't just toss aside the methods that have worked for generations."

"But Dad, the world is changing," Ethan argued. "If we don't adapt, we'll be left behind. I'm not trying to erase our history; I'm trying to build on it. But I can't do that if you won't let go of control."

Samuel looked at his son, a mixture of pride and fear in his eyes. He knew Ethan was right, but the thought of giving up control was terrifying.

"Ethan, I've seen businesses lose their way by changing too much, too quickly. What if we lose what makes us special? What if we fail?"

"Dad," Ethan replied, his voice gentle but firm, "I believe in our values and our heritage. But we must evolve. If you can't trust me to lead us into the future, then maybe it's time for me to leave and find my own path."

The words hung heavy in the air, like a storm cloud over the ocean. Samuel's heart ached at the thought of losing his son, his partner, his friend.

They spent the rest of the day in silence, each grappling with the weight of the conversation.

The following weeks were filled with tension as father and son continued to work together, but a distance had grown between them. Ethan's decision to leave was not taken lightly, but he knew that staying would only lead to more frustration and stagnation.

The small kitchen was filled with the rich aroma of cooking seafood, a fragrance that had been a constant in the home of Samuel and Annie for decades. It was more than a smell; it was a symbol of their life's work and their identity.

Samuel sat at the kitchen table, his forehead creased with worry, staring at a picture of young Ethan holding his first catch. His eyes, filled with a blend of fear, pride, and uncertainty, finally met those of his wife, Annie, who was calmly stirring a pot on the stove. Annie's concern finally broke through.

“Sam, what's wrong? You've been walking around the house like a ghost for weeks. I hear you walking around at all hours of the night.”

"Annie," he began, his voice breaking, "I don't know what to do. Ethan says he's leaving the business. He says I won't let go of control, that I'm holding him back."

Annie turned from the stove, her blue eyes locking onto Samuel's. "And what do you think, Sam? Is he right?"

"I don't know," Samuel replied, his voice heavy with doubt. "I've built this business from the ground up. It's who I am. My name has been on that door since I was twenty years old,” he paused and added quietly “Since my dad died. If I let go, if I give Ethan control, what's left of me? What will I do?"

Annie moved to the table, taking Samuel's weathered hands into her own. "Sam, our son has grown. He's ready. And he needs to know that you trust him."

"But what if he fails? What if he changes everything and our legacy is lost?" Samuel's voice was filled with fear.

Annie's eyes were gentle but firm. "And what if he succeeds? What if he takes our business to new heights, carrying on our values in a way that we never could have imagined?"

"But it's my identity, Annie," Samuel whispered, a tear escaping his eye. "It's who I've been for all these years."

Annie cupped Samuel's face, her touch both tender and resolute. "Your identity is more than the business, Sam. It's in the love you've put into every catch, every sale, every relationship you've built. And most importantly, it's in the family you've raised. You won't lose that by trusting Ethan. You'll only strengthen it."

Samuel looked into Annie's eyes, searching for reassurance, for truth. He found it in her unwavering gaze.

"You really think he's ready?" he asked, his voice vulnerable.

"I know he's ready," Annie replied, her voice filled with conviction. "And more importantly, Sam, I know you're ready. It's time to let go. It's time to trust that what you've built will endure, not because you're holding onto it, but because you've passed it on."

A long silence settled over the room as Samuel absorbed his wife's words. The fear was still there, but it was beginning to give way to something else, something profound and liberating.

"You're right, Annie," Samuel finally said, a smile breaking through. "I've been holding on too tightly. It's time to let Ethan take the lead. It's time to trust that our legacy is in good hands."

Annie smiled, her eyes filled with love and pride. "Our legacy is in our family, Sam. And that will never change."

As they embraced, Samuel knew that Annie's wisdom was his guiding star. Letting go was not a loss; it was a gain. It was an affirmation of trust, a celebration of growth, and a step towards a future filled with promise.


The next evening, as the sun dipped below the horizon, painting the sky with hues of orange and pink, Samuel approached Ethan, who was busy with the inventory.

"Ethan, I've been thinking a lot about what you said," Samuel began, his voice trembling. "I realize that I've been holding on too tightly, and I need to let go. I need to trust you, to believe in you as much as I believe in this business."

Ethan looked up, his eyes wide with surprise and hope.

"I'm willing to give you more control, to listen to your ideas, and to change," Samuel continued. "But I need you to stay. This business, our family legacy, it needs you."

Tears welled in Ethan's eyes as he embraced his father. "Thank you, Dad. Thank you for believing in me."

From that moment on, Samuel and Ethan worked together, not just as father and son but as true partners. They found a balance between tradition and innovation, preserving the essence of Martin's Seafood while embracing the future.

The business continued to flourish, and so did their relationship, strengthened by trust, understanding, and the courage to change.

The Martin family's story became a beacon for others, a lesson in the power of letting go, and a testament to the bonds that can be forged when we are willing to trust and embrace the unknown.

In the end, Samuel's willingness to relinquish control did not lead to failure but to a richer, more fulfilling success, both in business and in family. It was a lesson learned through love, sacrifice, and the wisdom to recognize that sometimes, the greatest act of leadership is knowing when to let go.

To learn more about a business succession plan that embodies a balance of your traditions, along with the innovations to come from future generations, click here:

About the Author


Stepanie Grubert Reply

Posted Aug 21, 2023 at 18:12:07

Hello Scott, I read your Family Business Fable with tears in my eyes. You are a gifted writer with your intensive liberal arts education. I appreciate my Fordham education from the same tradition every day. I don’t have a family member to pass on Mountaintop Eagle. Your family made the decision to continue your great grandfather’s legacy in a different way. I am a successful business woman and have never had more money going out the door than came in after 38 years. I am struggling for an answer to hand off my legacy and the history of Mountaintop PA to another person “Dedicated to Quality Community Journalism” my front page signature for rhe last 38 years. I will keep you in my positive thoughts. I wish you continued success.

Scott Lynett, Esq. Reply

Posted Aug 23, 2023 at 13:49:06

Thank you for the kind words, Stephanie. The handoff from generation to generation is never easy. You have been an incredible advocate for your community and steward of great journalism in Mountain Top. I wish you the best!

Leave a Comment

Contact Us Today

Legacy Planning is committed to answering your questions about Estate Planning issues in Scranton and Eastern Pennsylvania. We offer consultations and we'll gladly discuss your case with you at your convenience. Contact us today to schedule an appointment.

By Phone Virtual